Learn the heartbreaking but inspiring stories of Sal and Lena as they escape the only lives theyve ever known to build a new life together. Then she stabbed the other child. From the controversial start of reality TV to the birth of the internet, this eye-opening yet nostalgic documentary series will transport you back in time. I do agree with you that he was involved along with several associates. How did the glass get on top of those bloody footprints? When questioned about the time at which this took place, Gorsuch testified during direct examination that he looked at the clock and it was 2:40 am. What happens next? Let's say that Waddell is correct when he says that he saw a man come out of the front door and into the front yard when he first pulled up. There was also a lack of a blood trail or footprints leading outside of the garage. The spectators got a good chuckle at her expense when Shook replied scathingly that it was not. Through open records, Quinncy was able to obtain police reports and information on Arkansas's known associates. There have been numerous documentaries, a made for TV movie, countless websites and blogs, and several books written about the case. He stated that a fiber he analyzed from the grooves of the knife was consistent with rubber and fiberglass fibers from the cut screen in the garage. You either understand the effects of psychological trauma and the memory lapses that accompany it, or you don't. Arkansas had a serious drug problem, a vicious temper, and little to no impulse control. During the police investigation, one of the mistakes that hurt Darlie the most was giving several accounts and timelines of how the events occurred. However, since Harrell was an integral part of the defense team and had been sitting in the courtroom throughout the trial, any testimony from him fell under the "Rule of Evidence," meaning that because he was able to hear what other witnesses had said, he was not permitted to take the stand. Watch On Death Row | Prime Video - amazon.com Darlie Routier, 48, has been on death row in Texas for more than 20 years Her sons Damon, five, and Devon, six, were stabbed to death on June 6, 1996 She was found guilty of Damon's murder but. A guy like you would keep an accurate clock, wouldn't he? I didn't take the psychic's claim that it was a woman too seriously. Exposing the details of the CPR's Darin Routier did on Devon - HubPages Darlie told police that she heard the sound of breaking glass, and there were glass fragments strewn about the kitchen floor area. Viewers of The Last Defense, co-produced by actress Viola . The prosecution called a number of so-called experts and analysts to the stand. Seen lotsa ER people looking neat for the unplanned visit. None of her three trials were fair. Hmmmm. Of course, she didn't do that, because she knew full well the baby was fine. Or was he the victim of an egregious injustice? Some people theorize that the bruising was a result of Devon kicking at her while she was stabbing him, since he did show signs of defensive injuries. Darlie Routier: The Unknown Intruder Theory : r - reddit Nor do I believe that the vacuum cleaner was on the floor while Darlie was still in the house. He actually came from a decent, hard-working, all-American/God fearing family, and I think every night when he tried to sleep he would see Devon's face until he couldn't stand it anymore. Darlie Lynn Peck Routier (born January 4, 1970) is an American woman from Rowlett, Texas, who was convicted and sentenced to death for the murder of her five-year-old son Damon in 1996. At the time, Darlie had two different private investigators working on the case and feeding her (sometimes conflicting) information. He had entered the Potter County Jail in July of 1996, after carjacking a man at knife-point. The great news is that Darlie will finally be free. It would have to be proven that: the witness knowingly gave false testimony; this testimony had a direct influence on the court decisions and/or verdict; and that the prosecution was aware of the false nature of the testimony--which even I have to concede that they may not have been. Aside from his weight, the attack on Devon was brutal and swift. How do you handle your children when theyre misbehaving? The exhibit below shows a "DNA map" of blood trails belonging to each of the injured Routiers. Read allIn the summer of 1996, Darlie Routier fell under the shadow of suspicion in the murder of her young sons. This documentary tells their story. So I guess he gave them Terry's clothes? Harris, Dwayne and another guy. My belief is that the intruder did not go out the garage window. Worldwide attn & any further dna testing? About those towels: Darlie and Darin both have been accused of falsifying their testimony that Darlie was at the sink wetting towels to help stop the bleeding. My son was the exact same way from the time he was 2 months old, and still sleeps like that to this day. Each witness was able to hear what the others would be saying on the stand. A. I only remember them really by their faces. You can believe that or not, but I have an email from Bryce Benjet acknowledging their involvement. I know mothers kill their children; the idea is not inconceivable to me. Expert testimony typically plays well with juries, but a considerable amount of the analysis presented during Darlie's trial was problematic at best. According to the prosecution, Darlie cut her own throat while standing at the sink, and then attempted to clean it up. These worms keep telling lies. A. I guess, I'm not sure on how long it took him. that uses behind-the-scenes footage taken by Frye herself to show exactly what it was like growing up in Hollywood in the 90s. In Darlie's case, she probably subconsciously realized there had been more than one person, but since she only has a memory of seeing one of them, her confusion is understandable. How short notice? WATCH THE FULL EPISODE: https://bit.ly/309EnBPThe Routiers seemed to be a perfect family, until murder of two boysDarlie and Darin Routier seemed to have a perfect life with their three boys - until one night when Darlie said she and two of her sons were attacked by a man with a knife.SUBSCRIBE to ABC NEWS: https://www.youtube.com/ABCNews/Watch More on http://abcnews.go.com/LIKE ABC News on FACEBOOKhttps://www.facebook.com/abcnewsFOLLOW ABC News on TWITTER:https://twitter.com/abcGOOD MORNING AMERICA'S HOMEPAGE:https://www.goodmorningamerica.com/#ABCNews #2020 #Documentary #TrueCrime #DarlieRoutier #LastDefense The kids woke up, and all hell broke loose.". In the book, Cruz describes how Darlie received a letter in 1998 from an inmate at another facility. As if Rickels' testimony wasn't enough for reasonable doubt, we also have the affidavit filed by Darlene Potter. Many of the concerns you mentioned are actually addressed in the article, but no worries; we'll go one by one, slowly. Darlie's first words to the dispatcher were: Somebody came herethey broke in! I hope its the garage door to a new life for her. So please forgive me for not taking those transcripts as the holy grail of this case. She has also been charged with capital murder in the death of her six-year-old son, Devon, who was murdered at the same time as Damon. On Death Row - Series - Episode List - TV Tango Damon was breathing on his own; all they could do for him was pray that he could hang on long enough for help to arrive. So there you have it; all of the reasons why I do not believe Darlie Lynn Routier is guilty of murdering her children. Did Sergeant Walling ever tell her to administer first aid? This enables LE to compare unknown prints against known felons. I see. Darlier Routier Not Gone with the Wind. Darlie Routier has spoken to television presenter Susanna Reid in a documentary airing tonight (Thursday, December 10) on ITV. Darlie, who doesn't know what to do, is simply doing as she has been instructed. C Far be it from me to critique another author's work, and I can say that the article is very well-written and the author appears to be highly intelligent. A. I walked back over to where she was, and I asked her again who had done it, and if there had been any problems in the house, or if they had had any problems with anybody that she might think would have done it, and she told me no, and she kept telling me, that the guy was still in the house. Do you know who was involved in the insurance fraud Darin/Jag/ 1993? They testified that she did not appear to be grieving appropriately. WeWork: Or The Making and Breaking of a $47 Billion Unicorn is an original Hulu documentary available to stream now. It's kind of hard to disturb mulch that isn't there Ah, the infamous "sink cleanup." He began submitting open records requests of all inmates that were at Potter County Jail in the fall of 1996. Darlie Routier 26 years old when she was arrested on June 18, 1996 for the murders of her two older sons, Devon and Damon. Drake's father, Darin Routier, didn't take custody of him right away after the murders, because he wanted to get his finances in order, Liz Stevens reported. A. I don't know what Sergeant Walling told either one of them. Do you think the jury would of still voted guilty if they had saw all of the pics of her injuries? What kind of mother has bleached blonde hair and $5,000 breast implants? It's not like she was just standing there, chit-chatting with her girlfriends on the phone. It's not spatter, a splash, or even a drop. One of Darlie's non-supporters uploaded a video of him having a chat with Barbara Jovell about this very thing. Okay. On the night of June 6th, 1996, Darlie Lynn Routier made a frantic call to 911. You remember practically every word that Mrs. Routier said to you, but not much that Sergeant Walling said; is that right? True Crime. A liar already has their story prepared in their mind. His testimony states: "I thought if she was worried about fingerprints on a knife, she could certainly take care of her kids." However, community members Anne, Reggie, Barbra, and Dennis arent falling for the propaganda. Now the court orders testing on crucial crime scene evidence. Mary Rickels is a college educated Registered Nurse; yet these people gobble up the testimony of the alcoholic, pill popping and mentally unstable Barbara Jovell without question. The notorious killer, who is one of the longest serving death row inmates in the USA, claims she loves. JustinCase976 (author) on February 29, 2020: I do remember that Darlie said they had a psychic come to the house to do a reading. My theory is that there was no direct communication between Darin and the assailants; I feel like he would have preferred not to know the details. When it comes to courtroom trials, it's not about the truth, or even what you can prove. Even the best of the best make mistakes, sometimes grievous mistakes. convicted of the brutal murders of her. Darlie Routier, then 26, described how an intruder had stabbed her and her young sons, six-year-old Devon and five-year-old Damon. Okay. 6) I'm not even going to argue about the letters. Look at all the red spots that indicate where Damon went in the family room. 'The Last Defense': ABC and Viola Davis Come for Netflix's True-Crime Crown I don't believe the bloody jeans were ever analyzed or taken into evidence. Darin's Jaguar was broken down and was not parked in its usual spot in the driveway. Darlie later added, Im at peace with myself I did not murder my children, I did not attack myself. Darlie Routier - Wikipedia The media circled her like sharks, and, eventually, she was sentenced to death-row. This documentary features never-before-seen footage to tell womens stories over the last 60 years through the lens of the most popular plastic doll on the planet. I'd also like to add that I have been to this very neighborhood, and it is a six-minute walk from Rickels' home at 8910 Miami Drive to 5801 Eagle Drive. In 2009, Matt DeHart was persecuted by the American government for possessing child pornography, but DeHart claims he was framedby the government. Some people swear they have, other people say it's a load of crap. What is the oldest unsolved cold case? Making the call is Darlie Routier, the mother of three boys, Devon, Damon, and Drake, and the wife of Darin. He enters the Routier home and is immediately bombarded by two hysterical parents screaming (Darin: "Look for a rag! This would also explain why he tossed the knife down. Why hasnt anyone spoken to her? Police opined that Darlie sliced this screen with a bread knife from her kitchen to support her story of an intruder. Linch was instructed by the prosecution team to avoid recording his findings in a written report. But Judge Tolle overrode this. 16/06/2022 . Although the crime scene photos show that there was blood all over the house, what they don't realize is that the blood was not present at the moment the intruder left. I'm actually glad that you addressed that, Rachael. This fingerprint did not match one single person who was known to be in the house that night; it did not belong to any of the Routiers, nor did it match any of the police officers or paramedics (all were printed to rule them out). He may not have been able to see the ambulance from his bedroom window. There is no tone, no inflection, no facial expressions or body language. Watch: Minding the Gap The Orange Years: The Nickelodeon Story For so many, Nickelodeon is the cornerstone of childhood nostalgia. That does not, and never will, fall under the category of lying. When you think of the creator of Batman, you probably think of Bob Kane. She was convicted of Damon's murder on February 4, 1997 and has been on Texas' death row since then. Patterson. A song about violence and death at the funeral of two slain little boys? To eliminate this problem, they simply brought the dog into their room every night when they went to bed. DLR should easily be released. As for the accomplices that were with Tim Harris, if they get one of them to talk, I bet that they will throw Harris directly under the bus. "DNA map" of blood trails belonging to each of the injured Routiers. JustinCase976 (author) on February 28, 2020: I didn't know that but that definitely raises an eyebrow. The emotion, the anguish, the terror, the panic you're getting a glimpse into another person's living helland every parent's worst nightmare. So, I did the next best thing: I asked multiple sources close to the case, and received the same response from more than one person: Domain would be brought into the bedroom every night from the first week they got him. She picked it up and placed it on the counter before realizing that she and her children were hurt and called 911. Another thing i would like to mention the police accused the clean up at the kitchen sink when they sprayed luminol. Mother convicted of murder gets help from Innocence Project If Darlie is only able to relay bits and pieces of what happened, then obviously there is certain information, perhaps vital information, that is missing. LOL Fern! There's just too many variables. Their reasoning for this conclusion included the following factors and pieces of evidence, some of which, admittedly, did not look good for her: 1) A stab wound to Darlie's right arm that went to the bone (she is right-handed). Seeing those bloody, butchered children invoked anger in the nurses, most of whom were women. Paramedics arrived at the scene at about 2:40, and paramedic Jack Kolbye witnessed Damon gasp his last breath immediately after he began attending to him. SUSANNA REID reveals what it was like to meet the woman facing death Check out these true crime documentaries streaming now on Hulu. From Britney Spears conservatorship and Janet Jacksons Super Bowl scandal to social media influencers and even the popularity of vapingthis documentary series covers it all. There is so much information here! Darlie Lynn Peck Routier is an American-born woman originally from Rowlett, Texas. There were at least a dozen people coming in and out of that house in the early morning hours. When Darlie's court-appointed attorneys referenced this affidavit in a pretrial hearing, Greg Davis immediately objected on the grounds of hearsay and was (as usual) sustained by Judge Mark Tolle. After 22 years, Darlie Routier remains on death row for son's murder: Part 11 Defense investigators are still working to prove she was not involved in her sons' deaths. To this day, she has not been tried for Devons murder. JustinCase976 (author) on August 22, 2019: Thanks for your comment, Fern; it's always nice to hear another standpoint from a supporter of Darlie's innocence. There are other indexes as well, such as missing persons and unidentified human remains. Darin even did a fake CPR on his son Damon, 7 times. Do you have the links to the criminal's mugshots? Quinncy was intrigued enough to start doing some digging. Check out our list of these movies and shows based on true stories streaming now on Hulu. Could it be that his superiors strongly encouraged him to tweak his testimony to support the department's need to portray Darlie as the killer? 44 Best Documentaries on Hulu to Watch Right Now - Hulu Darin had appliedand been turned downfor a $5,000 loan on June 1st. so as Darlie the monster the prosecution. This is the totality of Devon's blood on the back of the shirt. So what's the deal with the Innocence Project? One has to wonder how much evidence was missed, and not collected for testing. Darlie later told officers that shed fallen asleep while watching television on the couch and had woken up only to find a long-haired man, wearing a baseball cap, t-shirt, and jeans, in her living room. Many of us look back on the 1990s with fond memories and nostalgiaa longing for the good old days.. Darlie's Pathfinder was parked in the street; it would have appeared as if no one was home. Where is Teresa Powers affidavit? She never could get the order of events right when she told the story. Amin Nawabi is an Afghan refugee with a heavy secret he has kept to himself for over 20 years. Inappropriate, he thundered. INFAMOUS: Darlie Routier (Part 1) Episode Summary In 1996, a small Texas community was rocked by the tragic slaying of two young boys. Even if they were, I'm sure the defense team would not want these people's names released at this point in time, as that would be counterproductive to any investigation that may be ongoing. The print is then scanned and entered into the system. taylormade tp putter weights. I wish you could say all the things too!!!! For so many, Nickelodeon is the cornerstone of childhood nostalgia. Who is Darlie Routier and did she kill her sons? | The Sun He also wrote to Houston attorney and former investigative reporter Quinncy McNeal, who was also named in the article, relating the same story. Instead of focusing on the wiretapping, Mulder could have asked Patterson the million-dollar question: "Detective Patterson, upon reviewing the footage of this surreptitious recording, at what point did you hear Darlie Routier confess to murdering her sons?". This caused the prosecution to claim that Darlie placed it there to further enhance evidence of a struggle. Where to Watch Every Christmas Movie and Special. I also think she resented the fact that in Poland, she was a Registered Nurse, while in America, she was reduced to folding someone else's laundry for $50. The state of Texas gave Darlie Routier the trial and verdict they WISHED they could have given Susan Smith. There's so many details that just don't add up. Guilters have been quick to dismiss Rickels as a "lying lunatic" or a "brain damaged stroke victim on a cocktail of drugs.". Darlie spent two days in the hospital recovering from her injuries, whereas her sons died. When Darlie mentioned the knife to Waddell, the dispatcher immediately instructed her not to touch it. Has cold justice solved any cases? Explained by Sharing Culture No one was concerned with trying to preserve a crime scene; the priority was to treat the injured. Investigators (and guilters) claim that Darlie's bloody footprints under the broken glass on the floor is further evidence of a staged crime scene. They already know exactly what they're going to say, and they don't deviate from it. She grasped onto what they told her like a lifeline, desperate to believe that the real killer would be found. Until that happens, I steadfastly maintain my position that an innocent woman has been sitting on death row for over two decades, while Dwayne, a recent parolee, is sitting back laughing at how he got away with murderand at everyone who believes in Darlie's guilt. However, detectives found this series of events very difficult to believe, especially as the evidence suggested that the crime scene had been staged. Zero evidence of intruder, motion lites not on, Domain was a barker,didn't bark til cops came,her knife, cleanup @ sink, her changing stories, N jail letters she named 2 men then cried on the stand when caught. into question. It makes sense, right? These fibers are also consistent with the brushes used for fingerprint dusting, and the knives were dusted for prints immediately after the screen, making a great case for cross-contamination. Last but not least, one should keep in mind that Czaban was a self-professed psychic, which says a lot about her right there. Darlie Lynn Peck was born on January 4, 1970 in Altoona, Pennsylvania. Aside from the supposed cleanup at the sink, there were other details that caused investigators to suspect the crime scene had been staged. Kriti Mehrotra. The bottom line is, I feel that Czaban's entire testimony should be taken with a pillar of salt. During the trial, the character assassination of Darlie Routier continued when several of the nurses who treated her in the hospital were called to testify.