We get to see this very pure young girl go through such a trauma, Reilly said in an interview. Why Did John Dutton Adopt Jamie? Jamie's Parentage Explained Beth was nervous which caused her horse to spook the horse Evelyn was riding. They'll tell you all the reasons why our way of life in Montana are bad for this country, bad for our future. Thats all I can say. How Did John Know Jamie's Biological Mother? I also think Evelyn (Johns wife) is the one who wanted to do it. Furthermore, she could have sunk into depression caused by the grief leading her to suicide. But there is a war being waged against our way of life. John Dutton | Yellowstone Wiki | Fandom The oldest Dutton sibling (Dave Annabel) died in season 1 during a dispute over cattle. Sister Wives: Critics Suspect That Meri Hired FAKE Guests To Promote Her Retreat! He has not yet made an appearance in 1923, so his exact spot in the family tree is unclear. Hence, it is likely that John's mother never recovered from losing her younger son. One perceptive viewer realised Jamies real mother was probably connected to the Dutton ranch in some way, thanks to his candid conversation with his adoptive father, John. However, the narrative does not touch upon Johns relationship with his mother. John and his wife Evelyn raised four children together. A level of bitterness and a resentment and he could've been the recipient of some of that. She seems to have been especially hard on Beth. The series is yet to name the character or address her involvement in any major events in the story. This may include adverts from us and 3rd parties based on our understanding. Who Is Garrett Randall on 'Yellowstone'? Jamie's Father, Explained By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. How it's immoral that you live here,work here, grow their food here. Evelyn appears in the series only through flashbacks. From there, things seemed to improve between father and son. Trending SR Exclusives Star Wars Marvel DC Star Trek The Last of Us The Mandalorian. Is she John's sister, a relative, or Evelyn's sister or relative?. He has an unnamed baby after a relationship with Christina. We don't share land down here.John Dutton to the Chinese tourists on his property. 4 Huge Yellowstone Moments That Made Episode 7 Feel Like A Finale Yellowstone Season 4 Finale: Beth Dutton wrath Another Cast - Deadline Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. John Dutton clearly was close to Jamie's birth mother well before Jamie was born," the Redditor explained. Read More: Does John Dutton Have Siblings? As a result, Beth would become infertile. Yellowstone's latest episode revealed what happened between Beth Dutton and her brother Jamie. The character has appeared as an older man in Yellowstone, and he is presumed to be the son of John Sr. and father of John III. Theory: Jamie Dutton's birth mother is a Dutton John Dutton adopted Jamie even though he despises Jamie's birth father. From a recurring narrative perspective, Jamie keeps making rash decisions, based on emotion and limited information, that negatively impact the Dutton family. Fans of the first "Yellowstone" origin series "1883" might recall that Elsa Dutton (Isabel May) was married to Comanche tribesman Sam (Martin Sensmeier), who she met while heading toward Montana . Jamie was born as James Michael Randall to a couple named Garrett Randall and Phyllis Mary Randall , who had quite a rough marriage. Led by patriarch John Dutton (Kevin Costner), the values of the family gear more towards the rustic day-to-day trials of being a ranch owner rather than Jamie's corporate lifestyle. He is the former Livestock Commissioner for the state of Montana and one of the most respected, powerful members of the communities from Bozeman to Livingston. Though some fans had follow-up thoughts, no one can deny that this would be information that would blow up Jamie's life. Evelyn Dutton was the biological mother of Lee, Kayce, and Beth Dutton. Who Is Jamie Bamber Wife? Is He Married? Kids, Age, Net Worth A big reveal thats simple enough for any degree of watcher to pick up on. In 1997, Evelyn went out to ride horses with a young Beth and Kayce. He owns one of the biggest cattle ranches of the United States. "It seems odd that a couple with the social standing of the Duttons would be that closely involved with simply a casual neighbor or friend." Other fans chimed in to agree. You covered everything. I feel like that is a whole lane that can have secrets in it we know nothing about. The Yellowstone Theory About Jamie's Birth Mother Would Complicate Things Even More. Kevin Costner has shared Johns clear perspective on his attempts at fatherhood, and to Johns credit, he has given Jamie a second chance after he betrayed his father on Yellowstone. John Dutton is the patriarch of the family who has been running the ranch for years. 21 Shows to Watch If You Like Yellowstone, 'WoF' Fans Say This Is the Biggest Choke on Show, St. Patricks Day Trivia Questions and Answers, Adam Sandler's Wife Jackie Shuts Down Red Carpet. It took almost all of Episode 7 for the breadth of that revelation to wash over Jamie, who later confronted his father over the truth. Both theories makes sense but the naming is too much of a coincidence. The person on the title picks the person it goes to after they die it can be Jamie, kacey, or some random person nobody has ever heard of. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. She was heartbroken after Peter passed away and never tried to have children again. A whole new can of worms to explore if T Sheridan wants to. Yellowstone season 4: Will Rip Wheeler kill Angela Blue Thunder? Yellowstone: TV series starring Kevin Costner from director/writer Taylor Sheridan. Is Jamie Dutton Gay? Exploring The Evidence From 'Yellowstone' ---- As production for Yellowstones next outing continues in Montana, fans took to Reddit to discuss further possibilities for Jamie when the show returns. (Check Out Their Favorite Holiday Tradition). However, the show has not mentioned the exact reason for her death. By my memory, Jamie has not shared any such heart-warming stories about his own childhood. However, Kevin Costners John Dutton is the Dutton familys present patriarch. This popular fan theory has not been confirmed in 1923 just yet, but the death of John Dutton Sr. in Episode Three of 1923 complicated the family line down to Costner's John Dutton III. ICYMI: Toward the end of season 2, it was revealed that Jamie's on-again, off-again girlfriend Christina was pregnant with his child. The ugly truth is they want the land, and if they get it, it will never look like our land again. Surprise parents and long-guarded secrets are tropes often found on television. Help came too late and she died. My ONLY question is this: wouldnt John have mentioned this to Jamie during their conversation about his adoption? Tate (Brecken Merrill) has grown up during the 5 seasons of Yellowstone, and he is the future of the Yellowstone ranch. (Like, does Jamie actually descend from Spencer's line and John has tried to screw him out of a rightful inheritance? I think there is going to be some "twist" regarding both John's parentage and Jamie's mother. As a result, she might have become withdrawn from the rest of her family. Newsletter. John Dutton III | Western Series Wiki | Fandom Future US, Inc. Full 7th Floor, 130 West 42nd Street, John's resentment of Jamie could come from bitterness that Jamie's father took away his sister from the ranch, which ultimately killed her. How Did John Dutton Know Jamie's Mother? - horseyhooves.com His father, John Dutton II, who retired from ranching due to his ailing health, died several years later of cancer, urging him never to give up the ranch to anyone under any circumstances, which was a promise John had taken to heart. Some believe that Phyllis was Evelyns sister, whereas others think that Phyllis could actually be a Dutton herself. 'Yellowstone' Season 3 Finale: Will Jamie betray John and - MEAWW The Dutton Family Tree - Yellowstone, 1883, 1923 Character Guide 'Yellowstone' Season 3 Finale Begs The Question, Who Shot John Dutton [2] During a moment of Beth's hesitation, Evelyn was bucked off her horse. That's all I can say. Sister Wives Janelle Brown Visits Christines Old House In Flagstaff! As with Johns wife, Evelyn, who only appears a handful of times, Johns relationship with arguably one of the most important women in his life remains unexplored. While the series heavily explores Johns relationship with his children, it does not dive much into Johns relationship with his own parents. You can unsubscribe at any time. Actor Kelly Reilly discussed the impact that Evelyns death had on her character, Beth. When Jamie was three months old, John and Evelyn Dutton adopted him. Kevin Costner's John Dutton is the most famous of the family patriarchs who now serves as governor of Montana. 'Yellowstone' Podcast: Who Is John Dutton's Brother? He served as a livestock agent and was set to take over the ranch for his father, John Dutton III. He is the protagonist of the series. Yellowstone viewers are unlikely to know unless a dream sequence around such a scenario were to get dramatized. Its land. The poster goes on to back up this theory with many interesting supporting elements. It is likely that John Dutton adopted Jamie since he knew the Randall family and wanted to protect Jamie from any further harm. The episode also opened with a . However, John's story doesn't have a happy ending, as he is killed early . U/Matthmil also pointed out that naming Jamie after the family founder could indicate he comes from the Dutton dynasty through blood. John Dutton III is a main character on Yellowstone. Beth (Kelly Reilly) is the only daughter of the Dutton family, and she helps run the family's business operations. . 'Yellowstone' Fans Are Heartbroken Over Beth and Jamie's Reveal in He is just a child in 1883, but is a grown man by the events of 1923.John, along with his parents, survives the treacherous route the Dutton family takes in order to settle in Montana eventually. I find it so interesting we know nothing about John Dutton III's mother. The Dutton Family Tree - Yellowstone, 1883, 1923 Characters After discovering he is not a Dutton by blood, Jamie sets out looking for answers. John loved his wife and her wishes to adopt him. Jamie will find out he actually is a Dutton through his mother, John is is uncle, and john deserves to be called dad because he raised him. The Duttons adopted Jamie when he was only three months old and raised him as their own. She was heartbroken after Peter passed away and never tried to have children again. She passed away on March 30th, 1997. In season three, John says that he knew Jamies mother Phyllis before she married Garrett Randall. She's a strong woman and mother of three (Elsa, Spencer, and John) who joins James in their perilous journey west, eventually settling in Montana. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). John Dutton figures she has killed her brother. Jamie Dutton is a lead character in the series, Yellowstone, where his campaign manager is mama to his baby. Why Did John Dutton Adopt Jamie? Jamie's Parentage Explained He inevitably realizes the information he lacked and comes crawling back to his family asking for forgiveness. Fan-favorite Rip (Cole Hauser) is the manager of the Dutton ranch and has been an unofficial member of the family since his teenage years. Albeit Yellowstone did see John hold back from hurting Jamie after the reveal about what he did to Beth. 7 Little Johnstons: Liz & Brice Hint They Have SEPARATED? Please refresh the page and try again. Upon being released from jail, Garrett tells Jamie that he k*lled his mother to save Jamies life. John did warn Jamie that one more betrayal would mean being dead to him, and viewers will have to see if the adoption bombshell pushes Jamie over the edge in that regard. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. John Dutton IV (adoptive nephew) Appears in Yellowstone No. That impacts how John sees and treats Jamie. 'Yellowstone' TV: Who Is Jamie Dutton's Biological Mother? - Outsider Season 1, Episode 1 of Yellowstone captured the tragic death of John Dutton's oldest son, Lee (Dave Annable). The two were set to be married before she was injured in the ambush by the sheep farmers that also killed her father. When her husband, Jacob, is injured, she takes over running and protecting the ranch and calls upon her nephew Spencer to come home to help. It's also presumed that he's the grandfather of John Dutton III (aka, Yellowstone's main character). How dare you destroy it.. After being sentenced to jail, Garrett hoped that his son would have a better life with a different family who could love him and provide for him. The Duttons were a prominent family in the area, known for giving second chances to people who need them. My personal opinion is that John may be blinded in some ways concerning how he has genuinely treated Jamie. an inevitable showdown with his adoptive sister, Jon Snow's (Kit Harington) "Game of Thrones" reveal. Sister Wives: Meri Brown Moving Back To Las Vegas? Jamie Dutton | Western Series Wiki | Fandom On how John handled parenting Jamie, Kevin Costner said: But he was supported and Jamie's manufactured that I had never liked him, that I was never good to him, that's something that he's made up. Her relationship to John Jr. and John III has not yet been revealed. DON'T MISS:James May opens up on pretty long days filming Grand Tour[EXCLUSIVE]Virgin River season 3 spoilers: Lizzie and Ricky romance sealed[INSIGHT]Lucifer fans tip season 6 time jump after episode title clues[THEORY]. Who Is Jamie Dutton Real Father On Yellowstone? - Caniry Question what you do and who you are. Evelyn was far from a perfect mother in Yellowstone. Evelyns death also had a huge impact on John. In one episode, Beth bathes in a trough and drinks champagne on the anniversary of her mothers death.